About Solutions Your data Your connections How it works Fractional Services Innovation Lab Insights Contact Client Login Start a Conversation
← All insights
Managed Care Optimization

Risk Scores Reset Every Year. Chronic Disease Doesn't.

2 min read

Under CMS-HCC risk adjustment, a diagnosis only counts toward the risk score if it's documented again during that calendar year — a real encounter whose documentation supports it (often checked with MEAT: monitored, evaluated, assessed, treated). A patient who's had heart failure for a decade doesn't carry that risk forward automatically. If nobody re-documents it between January and December, it drops out of the current year's score as though it resolved, even though nothing about the patient's health changed — only the paperwork did.

It's the calendar-year design of the model working exactly as built. Risk adjustment measures a twelve-month window, and a chronic condition that isn't re-touched inside that window reads, to the model, no differently than one that never existed.

The distortion runs in a direction nobody notices at the time. A health plan or ACO managing a genuinely sicker population gets paid as though it isn't, because the documentation that would prove otherwise expired on a calendar it never agreed to. Multiply that across a panel of patients with real, ongoing chronic disease, and the gap between the population's true acuity and what the risk score says repeats every year, quietly, and in the wrong direction.

A risk score is meant to measure how sick a population really is. When the measurement resets every January regardless of what's true about the patients, the score stops tracking reality and starts tracking who remembered to write the note again this year. The answer is a record that stays true all year, kept current as part of caring for the patient. When chronic conditions are revisited at the point of care, the patient's next clinician, the plan, and the risk score all see the same accurate picture. The aim is an accurate record, and every diagnosis in it should be one the clinician has actually evaluated.

More from Insights

Let's connect you to what your data already knows.

Tell us what is getting in the way. Let’s work on it together.

Start a conversation
What's underneath